vs.
SmartRecruiters

SquarePeg vs SmartRecruiters: 0–100 scores with evidence, not High, Medium or Low

SmartRecruiters is an enterprise ATS owned by SAP. Its Winston Match sorts applicants into Very High, High, Medium and Low bands, and its AI features start above the entry plan. SquarePeg gives every candidate a 0–100 subscore on each criterion you write, with the resume evidence behind it, adds company data the resume leaves out, and checks every candidate for authenticity in the same credit. It works inside SmartRecruiters, so there's no ATS to change.

SquarePeg vs SmartRecruiters at a glance

SmartRecruiters is an enterprise ATS with a CRM, onboarding and scheduling, owned by SAP since September 2025 and becoming the recruiting front end for SAP SuccessFactors. Its Winston AI includes Winston Match, which rates fit as Very High, High, Medium or Low with explanations, and Winston Screen, which asks AI-generated screening questions and ranks the answers. It also offers Winston Interview, Winston Chat and Winston Companion.

SquarePeg
SmartRecruiters
Screening
Scores every applicant against your criteria
✓
✓
A 0–100 score with a subscore for each criterion
✓
–
Shows the resume evidence behind each score
✓
–
Scores on company data the resume leaves out (headcount, funding, public or private)
✓
Unknown
Authenticity
Flags fake or misrepresented candidates
✓
Unknown
Beyond inbound
Rediscovers past applicants
✓
–
Outbound sourcing
✓
Unknown
Plain-language agent or assistant
✓
✓
Candidate CRM
✕
✓
Interview scheduling
✕
✓
AI interviews or screening calls
✕
✓
Pricing
AI screening included, no add-on to buy
✓
✕

Based on each company's public website and announcements, checked October 2026. Unknown means we couldn't find it described there.

See it on your own candidates

Score up to three of your own resumes or LinkedIn profiles in the demo, free and without connecting your ATS. When you're ready, connect your ATS and start with 2,000 free credits.

Start for Free
2,000 free credits
No credit card required
Try it without connecting your ATS

As an AI company, SquarePeg gives us a lot of credibility. It has saved us so much time on screening and improved quality of hire.

Tara Pramme
Head of People @ Laurel

How SquarePeg and SmartRecruiters compare in detail

SmartRecruiters is a full enterprise ATS with AI on its higher plans. SquarePeg focuses on screening and finding candidates, and connects to the ATS you already use.

Screening

SquarePeg

Every score shows its evidence. SquarePeg scores applicants as they apply, plus past candidates and sourced profiles, against criteria you write in plain language or generate from the job description, each marked Required, Preferred or Bonus. Every criterion gets a 0–100 subscore with a written explanation and the resume lines it's based on, so you review the best people first and can explain every ranking. Eligibility rules (location or radius, time zone, screening answers, a previous rejection reason or the application source) run first, so ineligible applicants are never scored or charged.

SmartRecruiters

Winston Match scores skills, experience, education, career progression and job-title relevance separately, then combines them into one weighted rating shown as Very High, High, Medium or Low, with an explanation. It uses resumes, cover letters and profile data, and doesn't describe company data. Winston Screen generates screening questions and ranks candidates by their answers, with weights for must-haves and nice-to-haves.

Fits your stack

SquarePeg

SquarePeg connects to SmartRecruiters, Greenhouse, Lever, Ashby, Workable, iCIMS, Recruitee and other ATSs and syncs your jobs and applicants. SquarePeg makes rejections and stage changes in your ATS just as if you had made them there, so your ATS emails and automations still run, and the Chrome extension opens it right next to the job or candidate you're viewing. No migration and no new system for your team to learn.

SmartRecruiters

SmartRecruiters is the ATS, so its AI works on your jobs and candidates with nothing to connect. It includes a CRM, onboarding, SMS, job distribution and scheduling, and SAP is bringing Winston into SuccessFactors.

Authenticity

SquarePeg

Every candidate gets an authenticity confidence rating (High, Mixed, Limited, Low or Unknown), kept separate from their score. It's built from LinkedIn, phone, email and resume signals, and it also flags a phone, email or resume shared with a differently named applicant. It's included in the credit that scores the candidate. Signals inform your review; nothing is rejected automatically.

SmartRecruiters

SmartRecruiters demonstrated "a prototype fraud-risk tool" in April 2026. Its public material doesn't describe a shipped fraud, ID or deepfake check as of October 2026.

Beyond inbound

SquarePeg

Rediscovery searches past applicants in your ATS for people who fit a new opening and scores them on the same criteria as today's applicants. Outbound sourcing finds new candidates outside your ATS on the same scale, and you reveal an email only for the people you want to contact. Every resume gets company context such as industry, headcount, funding and public or private status. And you can find, compare and fine-tune just by asking: the SquarePeg agent finds past candidates who fit a new role, compares your top applicants, explains any score, and can review and update a job's criteria and eligibility rules, in the web app or inside your ATS.

SmartRecruiters

An agentic CRM to surface and re-engage past candidates "is being developed with partners" and isn't generally available. SmartRecruiters doesn't describe a database of outside candidates. It offers Winston Interview, an on-demand AI interviewer, Winston Chat for conversational screening, and a Hiring Agent and Winston Companion for recruiters.

Pricing

SquarePeg

Credits work across every feature, there are no seat fees and no platform fee, and your whole team can log in. Scoring an applicant or a rediscovered candidate uses 1 credit; sourcing a candidate uses 1 and revealing their email 2. Rediscovery also has a one-time fee to index your ATS, charged at cost. Rescoring is always free, the agent is free, applicants who fail your eligibility rules cost nothing, and new accounts start with 2,000 free credits, no credit card required. See the pricing page for current rates.

SmartRecruiters

SmartRecruiters' Essential plan starts at $14,995 and lists no AI features; the billing term isn't stated. Talent Matching and the Hiring Agent start on Professional, and AI Candidate Screening is only on High Volume and Complete. Those plans are priced on request.

When to choose which

Choose SquarePeg if
•You want a 0–100 subscore and resume evidence for each criterion, not a band
•You want AI screening without moving to a higher ATS plan
•You want every candidate checked for authenticity today, included in the same credit
•You want criteria that use company data, like funding stage or headcount
When SmartRecruiters makes sense
•You need a new enterprise ATS with CRM, onboarding and scheduling
•You run SAP SuccessFactors and want recruiting from SAP
9 roles
run by a one-person recruiting team at Stash

"Most of the resumes I send to the hiring managers from the top scoring, they're like, 'Oh, yeah. These are perfect.' So it just makes my job so much easier."

Erick Smith, Talent Acquisition, Stash · Uses Greenhouse
Read the case study →

Frequently asked questions

How is SquarePeg's score different from Winston Match?

Winston Match combines several dimensions into one rating shown as Very High, High, Medium or Low. SquarePeg scores each criterion you write 0–100, marks it Required, Preferred or Bonus, and shows the written explanation and resume lines behind every subscore, so you can tell an 81 from a 64 and explain why.

Does SmartRecruiters check applicants for fraud?

Not yet, based on its public material: it demonstrated a prototype fraud-risk tool in April 2026. SquarePeg gives every candidate an authenticity confidence rating from LinkedIn, phone, email and resume signals, included in the credit that scores them.

Can I try SquarePeg before connecting my ATS?

Yes. The demo on our homepage lets you score up to three of your own resumes or LinkedIn profiles for free, or explore sample jobs that are already scored, without connecting an ATS. When you connect your ATS, you start with 2,000 free credits and no credit card.

How is SquarePeg priced?

Credits work across every feature, there are no seat fees and no platform fee, and your whole team can log in. Scoring an applicant or a rediscovered candidate uses 1 credit; sourcing a candidate uses 1 and revealing their email 2. Rediscovery also has a one-time fee to index your ATS, charged at cost. Rescoring is always free, the agent is free, applicants who fail your eligibility rules cost nothing, and new accounts start with 2,000 free credits, no credit card required. See the pricing page for current rates.

Last checked October 2026. SmartRecruiters details come from SmartRecruiters's public website and announcements; SquarePeg details describe the product as it works today.

Get Started Today

Start with 2,000 free credits

Connect your ATS and SquarePeg scores your applicants, checks every candidate's authenticity, resurfaces past applicants and finds new ones, with the evidence behind every score. Credits work across every feature, there are no seat fees, and rescoring is always free.

2,000 free credits · No credit card required